Skip to content
Power Up Gaming

PS5 Pro: Why Sony Aren’t Learning From Their Victories

PS5 console

Sony have finally announced the long-rumoured PS5 Pro prompting this writer to look up at the camera and scream: Why?!

It releases on 7 November for the cheap price of one month’s rent including utilities, £699. The price does not matter though, this isn’t my problem with it.

My issue is that it shows is that Sony isn’t learning from the biggest lesson that this console generation provides.

Prior to this announcement, Sony and Microsoft’s approach to this generation was similar in theory: they both acknowledged that fans were willing to make sacrifices to what their console provided in favour of a cheaper initial cost. The thing is, the two companies differed in what sacrifices they offered.

Sony decided to place their faith in the online generation, in that they offered a version of the PlayStation 5 without the disc drive and slashed the price by £90. To be clear, Sony’s cheaper offering was the same console merely without the disc drive.

Microsoft, however, had the Xbox Series S which also went with the no disc drive approach but expanded it, releasing it with lesser specs and lesser graphical capabilities than the Series X.  However, Microsoft did have the benefit of a much cheaper price point, with the difference between their two versions standing at £200.

Now Microsoft seemed to have stumbled upon a great idea, the price point was significant and did a lot to make it more accessible.

Microsoft’s big problem was… Baldur’s Gate 3?

The problem is, 2023 happened or to be more specific: Baldur’s Gate 3 arrived. This is the first thing that should come to mind whenever anyone reads about the PlayStation 5 Pro. It’s also the game that completely negates any point to the upgraded console.

See, Microsoft had a stance whereby every game that was released for the Xbox Series X had to be the same in terms of gameplay options when on the Series S. Baldur’s Gate 3 prompted them to break that. The game was released three months later on the Xbox following an attempt to make split-screen co-op work on the Series S, but it couldn’t be done. So Microsoft went back on their word and Baldur’s Gate 3 on the two Xbox consoles now has a definitive difference.

Baldur's Gate 3

Sony should have looked at that because it quietly vindicated their approach: Microsoft’s current generation of Xbox is split whereby one side of it is significantly more problematic for developers than the other. Microsoft does have a strong preference for gameplay options to be the same on both Series X and S, this wasn’t the ideal scenario.

This means Sony should have realised that for developers the perks of the Series X are fairly redundant when they’re operating under the constraints of the S, which is also the better-selling console of the two. Sony didn’t split their generation in terms of specs, so there was no difference in quality or what the developers had to plan for when making a game for the PS5.

Their idea won, the PS5 has reportedly doubled the sales of the Xbox Series X/S. Keeping the differences simple and easier to assess from a potential buyer’s perspective and making it more straightforward for developers has paid off.

To revisit the question: after all that, why the PS5 Pro?

So, with that mountain of context out of the way, I again pose the question: why is Sony going to release what is ostensibly the PlayStation 5 Series X? What is the point? Developers will plan for the PS5, not the PS5 Pro. There will be benefits, but they will not be massively utilised.

In fact, one of their biggest adverts for the PS5 Pro is its ‘games boost’ feature, which boosts the performance of PS4 and PS5 titles. It’s the former that I find a bit bewildering, as it’s clear the PS5 already has that. One of my favourite titles of the previous generation, Tales Of Berseria, looked and played so much better on the PS5 that I completed it again purely because it felt like a really great remaster.

Also, ‘Pro’ versions of consoles ignore the prime reason consoles have generations: it makes a clear cut of what is available to do on the developer’s side of things and means they have a steady few years of working with the same equipment. The jumps in what can be achieved are infrequent but generally quite big, yet this keeps consumers in a position where they relax about not needing to worry about upgrading their tech for several years. Games improve within the same generation because developers become better at using the technology available to them. A half-step doesn’t help, you just confuse the developers and your market.

It might lead to haphazard advancement, but it also simplifies things a great deal.

PS4 Pro
Developers sure, will have a bit of fun with what new angles the different technology offers in a mid-generation hop forward, but they’re a business. Their baseline has to be what the majority have and are using, so they’ll specialise it towards the base level of the console: it’s the lesson Microsoft should have learned.

Yes, there is the PS4 Pro, but it strikes me as very odd that Sony has repeated the idea in a console generation that has indirectly argued so well against enhanced editions of consoles.

The really great irony here is that I’ve had most of this article written for a long time, since the rumours first emerged. Yes, this is ostensibly the PS5 Pro version of this article.

The technology in this current generation still impresses me, I’m a very happy customer. It is a generation still breathing and in its comfort zone, unless you’re Nintendo in which case absolutely none of this applies. Thanks to the pandemic and initial supply issues, this is a generation that feels younger than it is.

I don’t think anyone is in a particular rush to move on.