Skip to content
Power Up Gaming

Chrono Trigger Composer Thinks Dragon Quest Should End Instead of Imitating Akira Toriyama’s Art

Chrono Trigger Composer Thinks Dragon Quest Should End Instead of Imitating Akira Toriyama's Art

Dragon Quest has been going strong for 40 years, and creator Yuji Horii shows no signs of stopping, even after longtime collaborator and illustrator Akira Toriyama’s passing in 2024. Square Enix recently unveiled another addition to the franchise, a mobile spin-off titled Dragon Quest RPG: Makaiki to Michibikareshi Shima (lit. Demon World Tree and the Guiding Island). However, its reveal wasn’t exactly met with universal fanfare, as some Japanese fans have questioned how the series is carrying on Toriyama’s legacy. Even Chrono Trigger composer Yasunori Mitsuda thinks it might be time to put Dragon Quest to rest.

“Dragon Quest RPG‘s Toriyama-san-styled illustration has become a hot topic, but for the illustrator, for Akira Toriyama fans, and for the now-deceased Akira Toriyama himself, I don’t feel this is a good direction for everyone involved,” wrote Mitsuda in a rather short blog post. “In my personal opinion, since it’s no longer possible to create anything new no matter how hard one tries, it might be time to end the Dragon Quest series, and for Yuji Horii to create a new RPG. (There are a lot of remakes out there, after all).”

The controversy that prompted Mitsuda’s remarks largely centres on the new protagonist’s design. Indeed, the artwork has drawn criticism on social media and forums among Japanese fans. Some have pointed out the oddly proportioned sword hilt and the apparent mismatch between the blade’s size and its scabbard. Others have questioned whether the illustration was genuinely based on Toriyama’s original designs.

Chrono Trigger Composer Thinks Dragon Quest Should End Instead of Imitating Akira Toriyama's Art

“Maybe an amateur employee just threw out an AI-generated image and passed it off as ‘Toriyama’s design’ when commissioning the illustrator?” speculated one 5ch user. “Even if they knew there were flaws, they wouldn’t be able to oppose a so-called Toriyama design, so they drew it as is.” Some fans also raised another concern: whether merely imitating the recognisable art style of the legendary Dragon Ball creator Akira Toriyama was enough to preserve his legacy.

“I think it’s understandable that it’s not the art of the real person,” another commenter wrote. “But if they’re going out of their way to imitate Toriyama’s art, instead of just superficial design, I wish they’d inherited Toriyama’s philosophy too.” After all, Toriyama was known for putting considerable thought into the practical details of his designs. One commenter on X argued that the damage lacked any visual storytelling, suggesting that scorch marks from a dragon’s flames would have made more sense than just random tears. “The cloak’s edge is tattered, but everything else is far too clean,” added another user.

Nevertheless, Mitsuda’s comments weren’t entirely negative, as he hoped that future generations could keep experiencing exciting new entries from the long-running JRPG series. “What’s important is that the younger generation of children who will play them from now on are given dreams and hope, as well as experiences that can only be had through games; that’s what I really wish for.”