Skip to content
Power Up Gaming

Inside a 15-Year Wargaming Authorship Dispute – and the Records That Could Settle It

For around 15 years, Sergiy Shashko has argued that he played a part in one of Wargaming’s most important expansions.

Shashko, a long-time Wargaming player who was involved in World of Tanks testing from 2009, claims that in 2010 he sent the company ideas for taking its military combat formula into the skies and onto the seas. He says he called the concepts World of Air and World of Battleships.

Wargaming announced World of Warplanes the following year. Its naval project also emerged in 2011 under the World of Battleships name before later becoming World of Warships. Wargaming’s original announcement described the naval title as the third entry in its planned series alongside World of Tanks and World of Warplanes.

What happened before those announcements is the part Shashko has spent years trying to establish. The original support tickets he says contained his proposals are no longer available through his account, while Wargaming has told him that records from the period may still survive in legacy systems.

The claim begins in World of Tanks’ early years

Shashko says he began sending Wargaming ideas and feedback through its support system during the early years of World of Tanks.

According to his account, his 2010 proposals went beyond suggestions for the existing game. One concerned aviation under the name World of Air. Another proposed moving the same formula into naval warfare with World of Battleships.

Neither the names nor the broad idea of expanding a military game from tanks into aircraft and naval combat are, by themselves, especially distinctive. World of Air and World of Battleships are straightforward extensions of the World of Tanks naming convention, while aviation and naval warfare were obvious adjacent categories for a Second World War-themed franchise.

Shashko’s claim, however, goes beyond the titles. He says he presented Wargaming with a broader expansion strategy built around moving the company’s combat formula from land into air and sea, alongside the proposed names and supporting concepts.

That is why the dispute cannot be resolved by similarity alone. The question is whether Shashko can show what he actually submitted to Wargaming in 2010, and whether those materials pre-dated the company’s own plans. Even if they did, that would not by itself establish that Wargaming copied them – but it would give a much clearer picture of what he was proposing, and when.

The original tickets have not been recovered.

The claim was on Wargaming’s desk by 2012

In 2012, Shashko raised the aviation claim directly with Wargaming on at least two occasions.

In January, he said he had sent the company the idea for a new aviation game around a year and a half earlier. In May, he was more specific, saying he had proposed a project called World of Air around two years earlier and asking about taking part in World of Warplanes testing. Wargaming responded to the testing request, but did not comment on his claim that he had proposed the earlier concept.

Other correspondence reviewed by Power Up Gaming shows Wargaming acknowledging at least one suggestion from Shashko and telling him it had been forwarded to the appropriate department for consideration. That does not identify the suggestion as World of Air or World of Battleships, but it does show that ideas he submitted were being passed internally rather than simply remaining at first-line support.

Shashko says he used the same support system to submit the proposals now at the centre of the dispute.

The 2012 correspondence does not establish authorship, but it rules out one obvious explanation for the dispute: that Shashko only began claiming the ideas after the games had become long-established successes.

The support history that is no longer accessible

Shashko says his account once recorded 144 support enquiries, but only 19 are now visible through the active support interface. He says the unavailable portion includes the period in which he submitted the disputed concepts.

A later data-access request produced a more revealing response from Wargaming.

According to correspondence reviewed by PUG, the company told Shashko that historical technical records from the period may still exist within legacy backup systems. Those records were described as being held in “cold storage”, no longer readily readable or searchable, and not recoverable in an intelligible form without disproportionate effort.

Shashko says he has kept his own archive from across the dispute.

“I have preserved a 17-year archive of emails and registration records,” he told PUG.

There is no evidence that Wargaming deliberately deleted his proposals. What remains is a more frustrating possibility: the records may still exist, but in a form that neither Shashko nor the public can currently access.

If the 2010 tickets he describes are among them, they could establish exactly what he sent and when.

What Wargaming’s own timeline shows

Wargaming’s own records and announcements establish part of the chronology.

The company announced World of Warplanes at E3 on June 7, 2011, describing it as a standalone free-to-play game being developed by the team behind World of Tanks.

World of Battleships followed on August 16, 2011. Wargaming presented it as the naval counterpart to its existing and forthcoming land and air titles.

Shashko later asked Wargaming when work on World of Warships had actually begun. Rather than providing a development-start date, support pointed to the August 2011 announcement and the game’s eventual release on September 17, 2015.

That still leaves one of the key dates unresolved: when the naval project was first conceived inside Wargaming.

World of Battleships was an established project name

There is no question that World of Battleships became an official Wargaming project name.

The company was using it publicly by August 2011, and the name remained in active use into 2012.

An archived job advert dated July 30, 2012 advertised an Art Director role for the World of Battleships project and described Wargaming and Lesta Studio as working together on the naval MMO.

Days later, Wargaming renamed the project World of Warships. Contemporary reporting said the change was intended to bring its name into line with the company’s other multiplayer titles.

Shashko also supplied a photograph showing original World of Battleships artwork displayed inside Lesta Studio. Metadata in the image dates the photograph to May 2015.

World of Battleships - Lesta Studio office photo

Shashko’s claim is that he was using World of Battleships before any of this, in the proposal he says he submitted in 2010. Whether the inaccessible support archive contains a record of that earlier use remains one of the unanswered questions in the dispute.

Wargaming described the games as a “team effort”

Shashko later asked Wargaming directly who had originated its naval and aviation projects.

For World of Warships, support told him that the game’s creation had been a “team effort” by Wargaming’s development team and said it could not provide the names of the individual members involved.

When he asked a similar question about World of Warplanes, support said details of employees’ work were not disclosed.

Wargaming did not identify a single originator for either project.

Lesta Studio developed World of Warships in partnership with Wargaming. The companies later separated in 2022, when Wargaming exited Russia and Belarus and said Lesta was no longer affiliated with the company.

A 2020 appeal to Wargaming’s CEO

By 2020, Shashko was taking the dispute directly to Wargaming’s leadership.

In an email he says was sent to CEO Victor Kislyi, he put his central claim plainly:

“I submitted the proposals for these projects in 2010.”

He again described the two concepts as World of Air and World of Battleships, arguing that he had proposed Wargaming’s move from land warfare into air and naval combat.

The appeal ended with a direct request for recognition:

“I hope for your justice, decency, and honesty.”

Shashko says Kislyi did not respond to the appeal, despite repeated attempts to raise the dispute with Wargaming’s leadership.

The lack of a response left the dispute unresolved and pushed Shashko to keep pursuing the claim through other channels.

What Wargaming’s terms said at the time

Shashko has also questioned the contractual terms that would have applied to any ideas submitted in 2010.

Wargaming’s current End User License Agreement, effective from 10 April 2024, contains a specific section covering “Feedback and User Submissions”. It asks users not to send unsolicited creative concepts and says submissions sent to the company are deemed Wargaming’s property to the maximum extent permitted by applicable law.

Shashko’s position is that equivalent provisions were not in place when he says he submitted his ideas in 2010.

There is some evidence of a difference in the historical wording. An official World of Tanks EULA last updated on 20 March 2012 does not contain the later “Feedback and User Submissions” section. Its intellectual-property provisions concern ownership of the game and its contents rather than setting out the current rules for unsolicited game ideas.

The 2012 document does, however, state that use of World of Tanks was also governed by a separate Terms of Service agreement, and says that document governed other aspects of the service. An archived copy of those separate terms from 2010 has not been located.

That means the 2012 EULA shows the current submission clauses were not present in that particular document at the time, but it does not establish that no equivalent terms existed elsewhere in Wargaming’s agreements in 2010.

The account ban Shashko says was retaliatory

Shashko’s main World of Tanks account was permanently suspended in 2021.

According to material reviewed by Power Up Gaming, Wargaming cited “forbidden modifications” as the reason. Shashko believes the suspension was retaliatory, citing its timing and the continued activity of his other accounts. PUG has not seen correspondence directly linking the ban to his authorship claim.

Wargaming

Wargaming was asked for answers

Power Up Gaming approached Wargaming about Shashko’s claims and the historical records surrounding them.

We asked whether his account submitted support tickets in 2010, whether any surviving metadata could identify their contents, when the aviation and naval projects were first conceived internally, and why historical records from the relevant period cannot currently be retrieved in readable form.

We also asked whether Wargaming had previously investigated Shashko’s claim, what terms governed user-submitted ideas in 2010, and whether his 2021 account suspension was connected in any way to the dispute.

Wargaming did not respond by the time of publication.

The records at the centre of the dispute

By 2012, Shashko was already telling Wargaming that he had proposed an aviation game around two years earlier. Other exchanges show that Wargaming was also receiving and forwarding at least some of his suggestions internally.

What those records cannot show is what the original 2010 tickets contained.

The relevant support history is no longer available through Shashko’s active account. At the same time, Wargaming has told him that records from the period may still exist inside legacy backup systems that cannot readily be searched or restored.

If those archives contain the tickets Shashko describes, they could show whether World of Air and World of Battleships appeared in his correspondence before Wargaming publicly announced its own aviation and naval projects.

If they do not – or if the records can never be recovered – chronology alone is unlikely to settle the dispute.

Shashko can show that he was making the aviation claim to Wargaming by 2012. Wargaming’s public record shows World of Warplanes and World of Battleships being announced in 2011. Between those two points sits the evidence that has not been put before the public: the contents of Shashko’s 2010 support history.

Fifteen years later, that leaves one deceptively simple question unanswered:

What did Sergiy Shashko send to Wargaming in 2010 – and do the records capable of answering it still survive in the company’s archives?