Skip to content
Power Up Gaming

Top 10 Soulslikes You’re Not Playing

Demon's Souls & Soulslikes

The year 2009 was a strange year for many fields. In politics, it saw the first ever African-American walking into the White House with a historic victory. In finance, it saw the launch of Bitcoin and finally in gaming, it saw the introduction to the world of Soulslikes.

This first came in the shape of FromSoftware’s Demon’s Souls. Demon’s Souls is a RPG like no other. Where in most RPGs, the objective is to stay alive as long as possible, in Soulslikes, the objective is not to avoid death, but to learn from it. With every untimely passing, you become a better Soulslike player, and with every death, you get closer and closer to reaching the end of the game. In addition to this, Soulslikes are punishingly difficult, with even the smallest of encounters often offering a chance to unwillingly meet your maker. A Soulslike is relatively easy to define as it often contains one or more of the following features or tropes:

It often relies on environmental story-telling, the usage of checkpoints that regenerate previously encountered enemies, a ‘flask’ health system which can only be refilled at the aforementioned checkpoints and lastly, the ability to regain any lost ‘souls’ or enemy essence if one returns to the place at which they last perished. So now you know what a Soulslike is, what it does and its purpose, let’s get into the top 10 Soulslikes you’re (most likely) not playing…

1. Code Vein

Possibly the most fateful Soulslike on this list – or any list to be honest – Code Vein is a anime Soulslike. Now you might be thinking “But Steven, surely that can’t be true, Dark Souls is a western GRITTY RPG”, to which I reply, the original idea for Dark Souls is actually derivative of an adult (not like that) manga series, which later became a TV series, Berzerk. Also, don’t call me Shirley.

Hidetaka Miyazaki, the series creator, repeatedly credits the Berzerk series as a significant inspiration for Dark Souls. He has also included references to Berzerk in the games in the shape of weapon descriptions and character appearances. It makes complete sense then that Code Vein would bring the series full-circle back to its anime/manga roots.

Code Vein arguably has more enemy variety than a great deal of Soulslikes (one could even argue more than the Souls series itself) and contains a change-on-the-fly class system which allows you to wield various heavy and tactical weapons to differing degrees of success.

The game’s score is among the best on any Soulslike, with encounters beautifully accompanied by operatic melodies. Combat, more akin to Assassin’s Creed and Dynasty Warriors, offers new experiences with each encounter, making it more rewarding and arguably more fun than the traditional Soulslike combat. This combat style may be especially enjoyable for those who struggle with the Dark Souls template.

2. Mortal Shell

Imagine, if you will, being able to don a fallen a soldier’s skin as a makeshift set of armour in order to prolong your life. That’s the offer which visually oppressive Mortal Shell brings to the table. Intended to be a Dark Souls successor but with a more emotionally-evocative atmosphere, Mortal Shell is a journey into all things dark and depressing, presenting beautifully with a Giger-esque aesthetic. Each battle – however small – has its own challenges and nothing can be taken for granted as every encounter is gruelling and difficult.

Generally being met with positive reviews, Mortal Shell really does carve its own niche out in the often-maligned Soulslikes arena. If you can look past the uninspiring levels design and enemy density issues which pervade every moment, Mortal Shell really can deliver an experience unlike most other Soulslikes. Even if it slightly existential in nature.

3. The Surge 2

Taking the Dark Souls formula, and dragging it kicking and screaming into the dystopian nightmarish world of Jericho City, the Surge 2 is the sci-fi update which the Soulslike sub-genre has been crying out for. Utilising its landmark limb-targeting system first seen in the first Surge game, The Surge 2 builds on an already successful DNA. This time bringing bigger challenges, more difficult bosses and an exponentially more interesting game-world than the first, which has more of a focus on exploration, than the moment-to-moment gameplay of The Surge which relies heavily on ensuring you feel helpless with every encounter.

The Surge 2 takes everything we love about the first game and injects a whole new feeling into it. Every weapon hits harder and every area is more interesting than the last, definitely a worthy successor and certainly one-of-the-best Souls-likes available.

4. Lords of the Fallen (2023)

Another remake on the list, is the reimagining of the 2014 Lords of the Fallen. Originally releasing to mostly favourable reviews, Lords of the Fallen borrows heavily from the original Dark Souls in tone and atmosphere, while also delivering a fresh take on the formula in the form of a few mechanics not seen in the Souls series thus far: namely the class system, which impacts the gauntlet the player utilises throughout the game to varying degrees of success.

The game was a solid release in most ways, however did suffer from some glaring technical issues that often led many to turn off and tune out, which is a pity because the game does have some interesting ideas, even if they weren’t ever really allowed to come to fruition in any meaningful way. Luckily, Lords of the Fallen (2023) addresses all of these issues and more.

Selling one million copies in the first ten days of it s release, Lords of the Fallen (2023) is, largely, a vastly different game to the original. What does remain is the gauntlet and magic systems from the original.

The game world does seem to be much more moody and depressing than the original and this is often off-putting at certain pivotal moments. However if you are looking for a Soulslike with something new to say, and a combat system which is just as rewarding and addictive as the original Dark Souls game, then you could do a great deal worse than Lords of the Fallen. Also, if you can overlook some of the technical issues, the original is also worth a try. Especially if – like me – you’re a fan of high-fantasy elements.

5. Thymesia

Not since Bloodborne has the Souls series touched on the often-forgotten Victorian era and all of its nightmarish charm. Luckily, we have Thymesia to make up for this shortcoming. Taking the combat back to the basics of the Souls series, Thymesia oozes Souls with every encounter, be it being surprised by ambushes predicted a mile away, or being pummelled by a boss you know that you should be able to defeat; it brings it all.

Straight from the Bloodborne playbook, the realm of the Kingdom of Hermes is knee-deep in a plague scenario that the main character can utilise to his own ends. While not offering the same staying-power as Bloodborne, Thymesia offers a beautiful campaign punctuated with horrendously creative bosses, as you shapeshift your way to a glorious – if predictable – climax.

6. Nioh

For many, the idea of throwing the Dark Souls formula into the Japanese Civil War era is something of a foregone conclusion. Both live and die on the overall impressiveness and interesting nature only deliverable via the lore and storytelling. Taking place in a fictionalised version of the Sengoku period, Nioh follows an Irish immigrant who is on the warpath for an enemy. During his travels he encounters the Yokai, who are a demonic presence infecting the lands of Japan and causing all kinds of mischief and calamity.

Nioh’s combat is unique, in that – like a large amount of Samurai-based storytelling with inform you – it is based entirely around different stances and how they impact the attacks that can be carried out. With each stance comes pros and cons, and each stance must be chosen in line with the enemy present.

Nioh is a dark and depressing alternate historical tale of loss, violence and exploration. It really does feel like you are watching a samurai movie from years past. Combining this with the Soulslike formula is a recipe for success which will surely see you spending many dark nights fighting the Yokai and praying for mercy from the many – at first – impenetrable bosses. It’s also a fantastic game to play on Halloween!

7. Remnant II

Remnant: From the Ashes was a weird combination of Soulslike and third-person-shooter. This instalment continues this tradition beautifully. Whether you are a bow-smith or a long-gun enthusiast, it has you covered. The original Remnant was a rough-around-the-edges experience with often unbalanced boss-fights and enemy density problems. Remnant II fixes all of these issues and even addresses some that weren’t immediately obvious.

It allows for deeper and more developed builds than seen in other Souls-likes, including it’s predecessor. While not as difficult as some of the games on this list, and certainly not as difficult as it’s obvious inspiration. It is a solid Soulslike third-person-shooter that offers hours and hours of replayability thanks to its procedurally generated levels and interesting combat mechanics. Unlike most Soulslikes in so many ways, but like Dark Souls in all the right ways. Remnant II is a great addition to the sub-genre and any Dark Souls aficionado will surely find something to love.

8. Elden Ring

The culmination of all the Souls games, Elden Ring does what noone ever thought possible. It takes the action-RPG series, and drags it kicking and screaming into the open-world arena – for better or for worse.

Possibly the best entrance into the world of Soulslikes, Elden Ring is familiar and alien, all at the same time. FromSoftware’s masterpiece boasts a sprawling game-world, with a story undercurrent developed in part with none other than Game of Thrones writer, George R. R. Martin.

The dedication to the series is felt in every encounter, no matter how small. Every area is beautifully detailed, and Elden Ring wears the environmental story-telling which the Souls series has become known for on its sleeve.

One would think that making the series open world, would somehow make the game lazy in places. This is so far from the truth. The delicately delicious detail that seeps from every Souls game is felt here. With every puzzle, boss fight and multi-layered secret, you will find yourself being enveloped by the Lands Between and all the monstrous creations you have yet to encounter, is it hard? yes. will you love it? absolutely no doubt.

9. Demon’s Souls (Remake)

Where would a Soulslike list be without the game that started it all? Demon’s Souls is arguably one of the most influential games ever made, that very few people have played. This is largely due to the fact that FromSoftware only made it available on the PS3 when it first launched. It was, of course, a stroke of genius to remake it for the PS5, but again, it is only available on the PS5 so again, it has suffered from smaller numbers of players in comparison to its multi-platform successor(s).

For anyone who first played the Demon’s Souls original, all the familiarities are still here in this current-gen upgrade. The monsters are just as viscerally beautiful as they always were and the combat is still as punishing as it was.

The reason that Demon’s Souls will always be a go-to for any masochistic FromSoftware fans out there is the polarising mechanic which – upon death – takes a portion of your possible health bar away. Many dislike this as it feels unfair, especially so early into the game. I however have always felt that it teaches you an important Soulslike lesson, you are going to die. It is not a case of if, no, it’s when.

Instead of holding your hand, as later genre entries often do, it ensures every encounter, no matter how trivial or easy it seems, determines whether you progress into the smoke to defeat the next big-bad-boss or get catapulted back over 15 minutes into the level you just emerged from. Yes, it is punishing, and it’s never been more delicious, Demon’s Souls deserves your time.

10. Another Crab’s Treasure

Not an immediately obvious entry into the Soulslike genre, Another Crab’s Treasure first presents as a cutesy ‘butter wouldn’t melt’ child-like game. With its colourful pallette and upbeat music, you might initially feel like you’re falling for a cruel prank by those who recommend it. However, trust me, you’ll be glad you gave it a try. Under its facade of juvenility, lies one of the most interesting and fun Soulslikes from recent years. It has all the trappings one would expect from a Dark Souls-like, with a few novel differences and additions.

Namely, the Sekiro-like bar that fills as you fight and allows you a few cheap hits before it depletes. It also addresses the idea of armour in a slightly different way, there isn’t any. You must instead find items around the map to don in place of armor, but all the items have pros and cons which makes it more interesting than a great number of Soulslikes.

One such instance is the sushi roll. As you may have guessed, it offers next to nothing in the way of defence, but you can ‘om-nom’ it halfway through a fight to restore health, so it really is worth the punt for those hard-to-beat bosses, of which there are many.

Another Crab’s Treasure wears its influences on its pincers and will offer you hours and hours of fun if you let it; just don’t go into it thinking it is a serious game, because if there is one thing it’s not, it’s serious.

Not always the ‘go-to’ genre for gamers, the bar for entry to Soulslikes can be somewhat intimidating, but hopefully the variety in this list might at least nudge you towards giving this wonderfully rewarding genre a go. After all, you really do have nothing to lose but your souls, and who needs that anyway?