Skip to content
Power Up Gaming

Ninja Theory’s Rumoured Closure Makes It Hard to Trust Xbox

Hellblade's Senua looking towards the viewer

On June 10, Xbox executives Asha Sharma and Matt Booty shared an email on the official Xbox Wire blog that they had sent to Team Xbox employees earlier that day. The email, which outlines Sharma’s plans for the next 100 days of Xbox, details her vision for the brand going forward, as well as the problems it’s currently facing. Despite having kicked off her tenure with some much-needed wins, the email Sharma sent makes for some pretty grim reading, as she doesn’t shy away from revealing the financial struggles that Xbox has had to contend with.

As part of her goal to “reset” Xbox, Sharma highlights a handful of realities that the brand needs to navigate. Not only does she reveal that Xbox will end this fiscal year off with a measly 3% accountability margin, she also notes that annual revenue for the company has declined by almost half a billion in the last 5 years. As if that wasn’t bad enough, Xbox has also been spending an absurd amount of money to manufacture its consoles, due to rising memory costs.

All of these things combined show just how dire of a state Xbox is in. Little did we know at the time this email was sent, however, that the situation would get a whole lot worse in the coming days.

Xbox is Reportedly Shutting Down Several Studios, Including Ninja Theory

New translucent green Xbox logo on black background

Rumours have been swirling around lately that Asha and co. are planning to shut down multiple studios under the Xbox umbrella. Not one studio, mind you, but a minimum of four studios, at least from what we currently know. These companies include, but are not limited to, Compulsion Games, Double Fine, Arkane Lyon, and Ninja Theory.

Ninja Theory is perhaps the most surprising inclusion in this list. This is not necessarily because of the company’s track record, but rather because of what Microsoft has recently done. Just 9 days ago, during the annual Xbox Games Showcase, Microsoft announced a brand-new game from Ninja Theory called Senua.

Though we currently don’t know much about it, this title is seemingly going to be a more action-heavy installment in the Hellblade series. Senua aims to continue where Hellblade 2 left off, but unlike its predecessor, it will place a greater focus on combat and action. That is… assuming the game ever releases.

Ninja Theory Announced a New Game Just Days Before Its Rumoured Closure

Senua's face

If Ninja Theory actually gets shut down, as rumours suggest it will, then there will no one left to finish Senua’s development. If that’s the case, then why did Microsoft even bother announcing the game in the first place?

It’s plausible, if not likely, that no one at Ninja Theory knew that Microsoft was planning to shut it down, prior to the news this week. Assuming that’s the case, this makes the decision to shutter the studio even more insulting, not only to fans of Ninja Theory but to the developers themselves.

Inconsistencies like this are something that Xbox has struggled with frequently in the last several years. The company seems to change its mind on a whim every couple of days.

Remember when former Xbox CEO Phil Spencer said that Microsoft had acquired Bethesda in order to keep its games exclusive? Or when Xbox marketing chief Aaron Greenberg claimed that Tango Gameworks’ Hi-Fi Rush was a big success in the eyes of Microsoft? How about when Microsoft promised to not increase the price of Xbox Game Pass prior to acquiring Activision-Blizzard?

Many People Find It Hard to Trust Xbox, And I Don’t Blame Them

Senua's Saga - Hellblade 2

Well, all of these statements have kind of aged poorly, haven’t they? Not only are all of Bethesda’s games currently multiplatform, but Tango Gameworks is no longer with Microsoft, and Game Pass’s price has increased dramatically following the closure of the Activision-Blizzard deal.

I don’t know what it is with Xbox that prevents the company from being consistent with its messaging, but it’s something that needs to stop. Right now, it is hard to take anything that Xbox says seriously, because many people don’t have enough trust in the brand. For me, the rumoured closure of Ninja Theory will be the final straw, simply because it’s baffling that Microsoft announced its new game just days before axing it. At this point, I would not be surprised by anything Xbox does.

Is Xbox going to cancel the upcoming Halo: Combat Evolved and shutter Halo Studios? Or is the company going to walk back its plans for exclusivity, despite having committed to it days earlier? Frankly, either of these things seem plausible at this point.

Xbox is Sending Nothing But Mixed Messages About Ninja Theory

A boss battle in Senua

Ninja Theory has had a somewhat rough tenure since its acquisition by Microsoft. The company spent upwards of 7 years working on Hellblade 2, a short, 5-6 hour game that apparently sold terribly on all platforms, if rumours are to be believed. From a purely analytical standpoint, I could see why Ninja Theory would be a target for closure. But when Microsoft is actively promoting the studio’s next game just days before reportedly closing it, the company’s decisions make little sense.

At this point, I can only hope that Ninja Theory finds a way to become independent from Xbox, so that it can continue to live on far, far away from the mess that its parent company has put itself in.