Skip to content
Power Up Gaming

Take-Two CEO’s Comparison of Physical Games to Vinyl Makes Little Sense

Strauss Zelnick from Take-Two Interactive

The death of physical media is near, but not for the reasons that companies want us to think.

Sony surprised its fans early last month with the announcement that physical discs for PlayStation games would no longer be manufactured starting in January 2028. This news was immediately met with a lot of backlash from the broader gaming community, but said backlash hasn’t been enough to convince Sony to change its mind.

Sony insists that the death of physical media in the gaming space is a natural transition, owing to the fact that digital downloads have been the dominant distribution method for the last several years. What Sony hasn’t told people, however, is that physical media is still very much popular. Popular enough, at least, to warrant its existence for the foreseeable future.

Physical Games Are More Popular than Companies Are Suggesting

A stack of physical discs

Leaked data from the 2023 Insomniac hack suggests that many of the first-party games that Sony has released during the PS5 generation have sold a considerable amount of copies physically. In some cases, certain single-player titles have had a practically 50/50 ratio of physical vs. digital copies sold. Despite this, Sony feels the need to get rid of physical media in order to boost its profit margins. We are fast approaching an era where consoles will soon cost most than $1000. In order to make up for lost sales on this end, it appears ending physical media is the best possible choice in Sony’s eyes.

Take-Two CEO Strauss Zelnick seems to agree with Sony in this regard. The gaming executive recently chimed in on the matter during a Q&A session with investors. When asked whether the death of physical media (at least on PlayStation) would impact Take-Two’s revenue, Zelnick assuaged all concerns and simply argued that the publisher’s business was already a digital one.

According to Zelnick, over 90% of the revenue that Take-Two makes off of its games comes from digital distribution. This means that, from Zelnick’s point of view, physical media is negligible in terms of its financial impact.

Strauss Zelnick Believes Physical Games Will Become Like Vinyl Records in the Future

Red and blue vinyl records

Zelnick goes on to state that, in certain instances, discs just “don’t really make sense for the consumer.” Since in most cases, players “have to register online to play,” he argues that the value of physical media has become irrelevant. If a player is already connected, digital is “all the same and much more convenient” compared to physical discs.

After claiming discs are pointless for consumers, Strauss Zelnick made another… interesting statement about physical media and its relevance compared to the vinyl market. Zelnick said that he’s sure Take-Two Interactive will have physical releases “now and then,” in the same way “that there’s still vinyl in the recorded music business,” but he claimed that it just isn’t viable in most situations.

Despite Zelnick’s best efforts, I’d argue that his statements don’t make a whole lot of sense here. The vinyl market is indeed niche compared to other forms of music consumption, but it is in no way a dying sector, in the same way that physical games have been described as.

Vinyl Records Have Undergone a Resurgence in Recent Years

A pile of vinyl records

In 2007, vinyl records started to experience a resurgence across Western and East Asian countries as the result of newfound nostalgia for old-school music releases. Vinyls were once tossed aside in place of CDs, cassettes, and streaming services, but in some places, they are now the most popular method of buying physical music.

In 2022, the Recording Industry Association of America revealed that revenues from vinyl records grew 17% to $1.2 billion in the United States. This year was the first time since 1987 that vinyl records had surpassed CDs in terms of unit sales. Other places like Japan and Germany haven’t had as big of a vinyl revival as the U.S. has had, but vinyl records are still a sizable market in both of these regions.

Research and Markets Ltd. states that the vinyl market is only going to get bigger in the coming years. They claim that the global vinyl record market size has reached $2.1 billion (in USD) as of 2025. Analysts apparently expect the market to reach $3.6 billion by 2034. While it remains to be seen if this will actually happen, it does show that there is still growing demand for physical media in other fields of entertainment.

Physical Games Are Still More Popular than Vinyl Is

A video game retail display from the 2000s

Now, what does this all have to do with video games and Strauss Zelnick’s statements? In gaming, the physical disc market is bigger than the vinyl record market, at least in the U.S. Back in March of this year, U.S. physical video game sales were said to have fallen to just $1.5 billion in 2025. While physical media has definitely been on a decline, $1.5 billion is still considerably bigger than the $1.2 billion that the vinyl record market generated in 2022 in America.

There’s also another glaring flaw with Zelnick’s comparison between the vinyl and physical disc markets. In the world of music, there isn’t a single company (or small group of companies) that handles the manufacturing and distribution of vinyl records. If one company decides to abandon vinyl production, there’ll still be plenty of alternatives out there.

This is not the case in gaming. Sony, Microsoft, and Nintendo are the only companies that manufacture physical video games. If one of them decides to stop making physical games (as Sony already has), then no one else is going to step in to fill its place. Microsoft isn’t going to manufacture physical PlayStation games, and neither is Nintendo. If anything, the death of physical media on PlayStation will only convince Microsoft and Nintendo to follow suit.