Skip to content
Power Up Gaming

No One Independently Checks If Loot Box Odds Are Real

Lootbox

When Apple changed one line in its App Store Review Guidelines in 2017, the games industry started playing catch up, it has been that way ever since. Section 3.1.1 suddenly required any app selling loot boxes to disclose the odds of each item before purchase, borrowing rules China had written first, because apparently that’s what it took to get anyone moving.

That one line is where this whole trend starts. Ten things worth knowing about where RTP style disclosure in gaming came from, and just how far it still has to go before it matches what a slot machine has done for decades without anyone making a fuss about it.

Point 1: China Had To Force Everyone’s Hand

China got there first, forcing gacha odds disclosure years before Apple bothered writing a policy of its own. Japan’s guidelines followed soon after, and only then did Apple turn it into a blanket App Store rule instead of leaving it to individual markets to sort out.

Google, typically, dragged its feet. The matching Play Store policy didn’t land until 2019, a full eighteen months later, and only after a US senator threatened a bill that would have banned loot boxes outright in games aimed at kids. Funny how that works.

Point 2: A Slot Machine’s Payout Number Isn’t Up For Debate

None of gaming’s progress gets anywhere near where casino gambling has sat for decades. Online slots publish their payout percentages as standard, most landing between 95% and 96%, no argument required.

Scroll through a table of the highest RTP slots and the gap is stark. Titles pushing 99% get ranked, compared and argued over in public, the kind of open scorekeeping loot boxes still only gesture toward.

Point 3: A Few Studios Didn’t Wait To Be Told

Some developers didn’t wait to be told. Rocket League publisher Psyonix published its crate odds a full summer before Apple’s policy existed, and FIFA 19 and Dota 2 rolled out disclosures of their own around that same stretch.

That earlier move gets buried every time this story gets told, since China and Apple make for a tidier headline. Credit where it’s due: a few studios landed on the right answer before anyone forced them to show their work.

Point 4: The Dutch Didn’t Bother With Half Measures

The Netherlands went around the disclosure debate entirely. Its Gambling Authority just declared certain loot boxes to be gambling, full stop, a conclusion no US regulator has come anywhere close to reaching.

The UK went the other way, opening a parliamentary inquiry rather than writing a law, scrutiny instead of a hard rule. Two very different instincts from two governments staring at the exact same mechanic.

Point 5: American Lawmakers Keep Trying And Failing

US federal bills keep showing up and keep going nowhere. The version introduced alongside Google’s 2019 policy change never passed, and neither have the repeats since, leaving app store policy to do the job Congress hasn’t managed.

Games press coverage of these disclosure fights usually ends up chronicling exactly that gap, what a platform demands against what a government puts into law, two timelines that rarely sync up.

Point 6: A Number On A Screen Isn’t Proof Of Anything

Here’s the piece gaming keeps skipping over. No slot reaches a licensed casino floor without an outside lab tearing into its random number generator and confirming the payout model does exactly what it claims.

Gaming Laboratories International publishes its standards for interactive gaming systems for free, out in the open for anyone to read. Nothing close to that exists for a single gacha rate or loot box table anywhere in gaming right now.

Point 7: Self Reported Just Means Unverified

A number a studio types into a disclosure screen is still just that, a number the studio typed in. A 0.6% drop rate for a top tier character is a claim rather than a fact until someone outside the company checks it against the code.

Casino regulators closed that loophole decades ago by refusing to let a machine operate at all until a lab had run the check first.

Point 8: Players Do The Auditor’s Job For Free

No one official checks these numbers, so players do it themselves. Datamined rate tables get torn apart on forums within hours of a patch, and outlets end up printing figures the publisher wouldn’t confirm on the record.

It’s a scrappy, unpaid version of what a lab does for a slot machine on day one, run by people with nothing to gain except being right.

Point 9: A Launch Week Rate Isn’t The Real Rate

Rates move by region and by event too, and regulators haven’t caught up to any of it. A title can run a juicy promotional rate for launch week, then settle back to baseline once the spotlight moves on, no announcement required.

Slots offer multiple payout settings as well, and the casino picks which one to run, but every option on that menu was signed off by a lab before it ever went live.

Point 10: The Road Is Clear But The Finish Line Isn’t

Eight years after Apple’s original policy, the trend line only points one way. More countries keep adding disclosure rules rather than dropping them, and app store policy keeps getting stricter instead of looser.

What’s still missing is the part casino gambling nailed first: independent proof, not just a number on a screen. That’s the honest gap, and it isn’t closing anytime soon.