Skip to content
Power Up Gaming

Early GTA Online Would Have “Compromised” Vice City and San Andreas

GTA 3 screenshot

Rockstar considered an early GTA Online built around GTA 3, but pursuing the project would have “compromised Vice City and San Andreas”, according to former technical director Obbe Vermeij.

Speaking to MattJ155 in an interview marking GTA 3’s 25th anniversary, Vermeij explained that the team believed an ambitious online game was possible. However, the challenges of supporting it – and the resources it would have diverted from subsequent games – made it too risky.

“If we’d started doing a GTA Online after GTA 3, obviously we would have compromised Vice City and San Andreas,” he said.

“From our point of view, yeah, we’d love to do it, and we really did [want to], but it would have just been such a big risk that it just wasn’t worth it.”

Gang wars were central to the early online concept

Vermeij discussed the proposal after being asked whether the GTA 3 Online concept outlined in a leaked design document would have been feasible at the time.

He recalled Rockstar New York arranging for developers from the studio he remembered as Barking Dog, later known as Rockstar Vancouver, to visit the team during the Grand Theft Auto III and Vice City era. Their task was to explore the feasibility of an online experience based on GTA 3.

“We had a couple of meetings and they had some interesting ideas,” he said. “It was going to be mostly about sort of gang wars and stuff like that.”

Vermeij compared the proposed experience to the modern GTA Online in broad terms. Crucially, he said the developers did believe they could build something along those lines.

The concern was what that commitment would mean for the rest of the series. Taking on a substantial online project after Grand Theft Auto III would have drawn resources away from Vice City and San Andreas, making it a difficult proposition even for a team enthusiastic about the idea.

Server costs made an online GTA a bigger gamble

The other major obstacle, according to Vermeij, was the infrastructure needed to keep an online game running.

He contrasted the situation at the time with modern cloud services, which allow developers to increase server capacity without buying and installing all the hardware themselves.

For an online game operating its own servers, an unexpectedly successful launch could create an immediate problem. Too many players would overwhelm the available capacity, forcing the company to order additional machines.

By the time those servers arrived and were ready to use, frustrated players might already have abandoned the game.

Vermeij described that as a significant challenge for online games of the period. It meant Rockstar would have been taking on both the development demands of a major new project and the uncertainty of supporting its audience after launch.

The proposal was separate from the smaller GTA 3 multiplayer prototype Vermeij has discussed previously. That basic deathmatch mode had working gameplay, but was dropped when the team assessed the additional work required for features such as lobbies and synchronised mission scripts.

The broader online concept presented a different question: whether Rockstar should commit to building and operating an online GTA at the expense of other projects. In Vermeij’s recollection, protecting the development of Vice City and San Andreas helped settle it.