Skip to content
Power Up Gaming

Miyamoto on AI vs. Human Talent: ‘There’s Still Plenty We Can Do’

Photo: Jan Graber, Shigeru Miyamoto at E3 2013, licensed under CC BY-SA 3.0 DE

Shigeru Miyamoto thinks generative AI could push game developers to confront a problem that existed long before the technology: confusing the satisfaction of doing the work with making something good.

The Mario and Zelda creator discussed AI during an October 22 press conference at Nintendo’s Kyoto headquarters, held ahead of the announcement that he had been selected for Japan’s Order of Culture. He’s the first recipient from the video game industry. Famitsu

Asked whether human talent still has a place as AI makes creation easier, Miyamoto drew a distinction between designing something and carrying out the tasks needed to finish it.

“We always distinguish between ‘creating’ and ‘doing the work,’” he said, translated from Japanese, in a Q&A published by Denfaminicogamer.

His concern is that the work itself can be enjoyable enough to cloud a creator’s judgment. Filling gaps and polishing a project can feel productive without necessarily producing a strong design. Having AI handle more of those tasks, he argued, could encourage people to think more seriously about what they’re actually creating.

Miyamoto compared the shift to computers taking over technical skills such as drawing neat lettering. Once software made those tasks easier, a person’s sense of layout and design became more apparent. Better tools could also reveal talent in people who previously lacked the technical skills to express it.

For Miyamoto, what gives a design lasting value is the individual’s intention behind it, with computers helping carry out the work.

He didn’t rule out AI eventually taking on the creative part, too. But his assessment of the present was straightforward: “There’s still plenty we can do.”

Andi Nuruljihad

Andi mastered the rocket jump in the House of Chthon and honed his bunnyhop in the mean streets of town2.

View all articles