Skip to content
Power Up Gaming

What France’s Proposed Internet Tax Could Mean for Game Companies

Image by By Jebulon - Own work, CC0

French gamers could face higher subscription prices and new pressure on downloads if a proposed tax on internet traffic becomes law. The charge would fall on companies delivering the data, but players could ultimately feel the effects when downloading a game, installing an update or streaming one from the cloud.

What Has France Actually Approved?

France’s National Assembly has approved an amendment to the 2027 budget bill. It hasn’t introduced a tax that players or companies must already pay.

The parliamentary record shows that the amendment passed on 30 October by 11 votes to 10. There were 35 participants in the vote, with 21 votes expressed. Both the government and the budget committee’s general rapporteur opposed it.

The proposal would charge content providers €0.055 for each gigabyte delivered to French internet customers. Although attention has centred on streaming giants, the amendment explicitly mentions video games among the sectors delivering large amounts of data relative to their revenue.

That makes its potential gaming impact much broader than a charge on watching YouTube or Netflix.

What Could It Mean for Game Downloads?

At the proposed rate, delivering a 100 GB download would produce an uncapped tax calculation of €5.50. For 200 GB, it would be €11. A further 50 GB update would add €2.75. These are illustrative transfer sizes, rather than confirmed sizes for particular games.

Those figures don’t mean players would pay an extra €5.50 whenever they download a 100 GB game. The tax has limits tied to a company’s sales revenue: 15% of French revenue or 2% of worldwide revenue. For example, under the French revenue limit, a company making €1 million in France would pay no more than €150,000—even if its data usage produced a €200,000 tax calculation. What that means for customers isn’t yet clear. Companies could absorb the cost or pass some of it on through higher prices.

Even so, the mechanism would attach a cost to delivering data after a purchase. Reinstalling a game or downloading another update could generate more taxable traffic without producing another sale.

Companies could absorb the expense, spread it across their customers or adjust French prices and subscriptions. None of those responses is an announced outcome, and players shouldn’t assume they would receive a separate charge for every download.

Responsibility within the distribution chain would also matter. Developers, publishers, storefronts and delivery providers aren’t necessarily the same company. Implementation and commercial agreements would shape how costs reach studios.

Could Smaller Downloads Help?

One potentially useful response would be smaller downloads. A stronger financial incentive to reduce traffic could encourage developers to separate optional content and improve how updates are packaged.

That work already happens. Valve’s Steamworks documentation explains that Steam compresses downloaded data and normally delivers only the changed portions needed for an update. It also warns that certain ways of packaging files can make patches unnecessarily large.

This creates an important distinction: a game’s installed size isn’t necessarily its download size. A title occupying 150 GB on an SSD may transfer considerably less data over the internet.

Physical copies could reduce the initial download where playable data is included on the disc or cartridge. They wouldn’t eliminate downloads for patches, expansions or missing content.

Could This Give Physical Games a Boost?

A blank physical game disc being inserted into an Xbox Series X
The proposed tax could make physical media more attractive to publishers.

The proposal could give supporters of physical games a fresh argument—and publishers another reason to keep making them. If delivering game data becomes more expensive, supplying it on a disc or cartridge could become more attractive.

For French players, a physical copy containing the full game could avoid a large initial download. It could also let them reinstall it later without downloading everything again. If companies pass download costs on through higher digital prices, that could make physical editions more appealing.

That wouldn’t guarantee cheaper boxed games. Manufacturing, packaging and distribution still cost money, and publishers would have to weigh those expenses against any tax savings.

The benefit would also depend on what’s actually in the box. Nintendo’s Switch 2 game-key cards, for example, require players to download the full game. Those releases would offer little advantage in reducing download traffic. Even copies containing the game would still leave players downloading any patches or expansions they wanted.

Why Cloud Gaming Could Feel It Most

Cloud gaming presents a different challenge. Instead of downloading a game and running it locally, players receive a continuous video stream while their inputs travel back to a remote machine. The traffic continues throughout a session.

Nvidia’s GeForce NOW requirements illustrate how bandwidth needs rise with streaming quality. It lists connection requirements of 25 Mbps for 1080p at 60 frames per second and 45 Mbps for 4K at 120 frames per second. Those are connection requirements, rather than measurements of constant consumption.

For a separate illustration, a service actually delivering 10 GB per hour would generate an uncapped calculation of €0.55 per hour. Across 100 hours, that becomes €55.

That isn’t an estimate of a particular provider’s eventual bill. It does show why streaming businesses would scrutinise the proposal. Possible responses could include higher subscriptions, different allowances or stronger incentives to use lower streaming quality.

Ordinary online multiplayer shouldn’t be confused with cloud gaming. A game running on a player’s own machine doesn’t need to receive its entire picture as a video stream.

Could Higher Costs Mean Fewer Services?

The concern about who pays was raised during the French debate. Budget rapporteur Philippe Juvin warned that large platforms could pass the expense to advertisers. Minister David Amiel argued that a substantial share would fall on smaller content providers, including French companies.

Supporter Laurent Lhardit defended the measure as a way to make major international digital businesses contribute more fairly.

South Korea offers a relevant warning about expensive data delivery, although its system is different.

When Twitch announced the closure of its Korean business, effective February 2024, it cited network fees that were “10 times more expensive than in most other countries”. It had already tried reducing costs, including limiting streams to 720p.

That doesn’t establish that services would leave France. Twitch’s account concerned network charges; the French amendment proposes a state tax. It does demonstrate that delivery costs can influence which features—and businesses—remain available.

Will Other Countries Follow France?

The evidence points to an ongoing international argument, but it doesn’t look like any other countries in the EU will be following France’s example anytime soon.

A European Parliament briefing on the proposed Digital Networks Act describes the debate over making major traffic-generating platforms contribute to network costs. The Commission’s proposal instead takes a lighter approach involving voluntary conciliation between businesses. It doesn’t establish France’s proposed per-gigabyte tax.

There is resistance, too. The European Economic and Social Committee has recommended excluding mandatory traffic-based payments from that framework, warning about potential effects on competition and net neutrality.

In the UK, Ofcom’s October 2023 review found insufficient evidence to support allowing internet providers to charge content companies for carrying traffic. It said such a change would be for government and Parliament.

Those debates concern network fees rather than an identical state tax, but they show why adoption elsewhere cannot be assumed.

Andi Nuruljihad

Andi mastered the rocket jump in the House of Chthon and honed his bunnyhop in the mean streets of town2.

View all articles