Skip to content
Power Up Gaming

Why Linearity Is Never a Bad Thing in Video Games

Linearity

Linearity is never a bad thing in game design, and I’ve never understood why so many game critics, industry pundits, and YouTubers talk about it like it’s the plague. Sure, adding stuff like multiplayer, an open-world, or a complex plot can make your game more appealing to the general public, but they can also be considered yet another example of kitchen sink design that ends up overly complicating things.

Spyro the Dragon

There’s just something so fun and pure about completing a title in around four to five hours instead of slowly chipping away at a boring open world with copied and pasted content and an uninteresting story. That’s not to say these kinds of games are bad or shouldn’t exist because I still really like them, but as more come out, they become less and less exciting. I distinctly remember so many areas of Earthbound, Super Mario World, and Spyro the Dragon. But can I do the same for Zelda: Tears of the Kingdom? No, not really.

Plus, linear games are inherently more replayable because there’s less time for your mind to wander, and you’re almost consistently engaged. I can’t count how many times I’ve replayed the 2D Metroid games, especially Metroid Dread, but now that I’m on my second playthrough of Tears of the Kingdom, my play sessions keep getting shorter because I’m releasing just how much is repeated. Wait, didn’t I just say that memorability is a good thing? Well, yes, but I meant that in a more negative sense in regards to Zelda because, to be perfectly blunt, these massive AAA games mostly hinge on your first playthrough and not much else.

To be more specific, though, many people pretend that when games give you a lot of choices, they also give you a lot of freedom. That’s not the case at all because to be a game, in the first place, it has to provide you with an objective so that freedom ends up resulting in side quests that are almost always not worth your time and a bloated game length.

Linearity

Now, you could make the argument that a title having over a hundred hours of content can be a good thing because it can last you for months, but personally, I’d rather have a good pizza with pepperoni and cheese that I can finish in a few minutes, instead of one with a bunch of toppings on it that feel like they’re only there because someone else put them on theirs. In other words, I really respect the purity of an experience that I can see myself replaying again and again.

I don’t need my games to have every feature under the sun, a huge multiplayer component, and an engaging and deep story with complex characters. Sometimes, I just want to sit down for a few hours, have a good time, and be done with it. Is that too much to ask? If it is, then I’ll keep holding onto my Super Nintendo and PS2 until people finally wake up and smell the roses…