Skip to content
Power Up Gaming

The Online Reaction to Xbox’s Layoffs Have Missed the Bigger Picture

Xbox logo

Xbox and layoffs; name a more iconic duo.

In the last few years, following the closure of the Activision-Blizzard acquisition, Xbox has fired thousands upon thousands of people within its divisions. The firm first laid off 1,900 employees, or around 9% of its workforce, in January 2024. Then, in May of that year, it shuttered a whopping four studios, one of which (Tango Gameworks) was later sold to Korean publisher Krafton a few months later.

July 2025 was a similarly rough period for the platform holder. During this month, Xbox owner Microsoft laid off 9,000 employees across many of its subsidiaries. This resulted in the closure of Perfect Dark developer The Initiative, as well as the cancellation of titles like Zenimax Online’s Project Blackbird.

Xbox Has Been Hit Hard With Layoffs… Yet Again

New translucent green Xbox logo on black background

Fast-forward a year later and, despite Xbox now being under new management with CEO Asha Sharma at the helm, the firm has been hit with mass layoffs yet again. This time, no studios have been closed, but many beloved developers, such as Doom creator id Software and Fallout: New Vegas maker Obsidian Entertainment, have been impacted really hard. Rumour has it, in fact, that around half of id’s team has been laid off, with many of its affected members having spent decades at the company.

Five studios – Double Fine, Compulsion Games, Undead Labs, Ninja Theory, and Arkane Lyon – will be leaving Xbox in the near future, either by going independent or by being sold to another company. As for the rest? Well, it seems like they will only be working on major IPs going forward.

Asha Sharma has made it clear that Xbox is not in a healthy place. Not only has its console brand stagnated, but many of its recent titles have outright underperformed. As a result, the firm has decided to focus more on surefire hits, rather than risky bets in the future.

Obsidian Entertainment – the Xbox subsidiary behind 2025’s Avowed and The Outer Worlds 2 – is now reported to be working on a new Fallout game, instead of a sequel to Avowed. id Software, meanwhile, will seemingly shift its focus towards new Doom and Quake games, rather than making a new IP, as it had initially planned.

The Latest Xbox Layoffs Are Terrible, But Not that Surprising

Three Xbox Series consoles

This sort of strategy is seemingly going to be embraced by many studios under Xbox and, frankly, I don’t blame Microsoft for taking this path. Despite all the devastating job cuts that have occurred in the last few days, it seems like, for once, there is at least some rhyme and reason to what has happened at Xbox. That’s why I’ve kind of been surprised by some of the reactions that people have had to these layoffs.

I’ve seen many pundits online who have been quick to blame corporate greed, unchecked capitalism, and CEO bonuses on the layoffs at Xbox. Believe me, I’m not a big fan of Microsoft and corporate shenanigans, either. But I think, this time, there is actually an understandable (although not necessarily good) reason as to why all this fallout at Xbox has occurred.

That reason? The majority of the games Xbox has released in the last few years have simply failed to attract a wide-enough audience.

Most of Xbox’s Studios Haven’t Released Commercially Successful Games

Characters from Bleeding Edge

In 2018, Xbox brought 7 studios under its umbrella. These were Playground Games, Ninja Theory, Obsidian Entertainment, Undead Labs, inExile Entertainment, Compulsion Games, and The Initiative. Then, in 2019, it acquired Double Fine.

Among these 8 studios, 3 of them haven’t released a single Xbox-published game following their acquisition by Microsoft. Undead Labs is still working on the upcoming State of Decay 3, after more than six years since its announcement, while inExile Entertainment is making the Xbox exclusive Clockwork Revolution, set to launch in 2027. The Initiative, meanwhile, was shut down, after taking 7 years to release nothing.

As for the other studios, almost none of them have had a consistent output of releases in the last 7 to 8 years. Ninja Theory released the failed multiplayer game, Bleeding Edge, and the 7-hour-long Hellblade 2 over the span of nearly a decade. Compulsion Games, meanwhile, took 7 years to release the action-adventure title, South of Midnight, a game that barely anyone played, despite receiving positive reviews.

The Output from Double Fine and Obsidian Has Been Mixed

Avowed

Double Fine and Obsidian are a bit of a different story. While these two studios have both launched multiple games, most of them haven’t been successful. Double Fine released 3 games under Microsoft, those being Psychonauts 2, Keeper, and Kiln. Although Psychonauts 2 seemed to do well for itself when it debuted in 2021, Keeper and Kiln were decidedly more niche and they, thus, failed to find many players.

Xbox has published a whopping 5 titles from Obsidian so far: those were Grounded, Pentiment, Avowed, The Outer Worlds 2, and Grounded 2. Among these titles, only the Grounded games seem to have done well commercially. Though Avowed and The Outer Worlds 2 had their fans, they were torn to shreds by many people online upon their respective debuts, with some arguing that Obsidian had “died” and was no longer as good as it once was. Pentiment, meanwhile, was beloved, but niche.

Playground Games is probably the only studio purchased by Microsoft during this acquisition spree that has actually produced games that large groups of people want. Forza Horizon 4, 5, and 6 have all done incredibly well from a commercial standpoint. Assuming it lives up to expectations, 2027’s Fable reboot seems like it will be a smash hit, as well.

Even the legendary id Software wasn’t able to release a game as successful as the recent Forza Horizon titles, under Microsoft. 2025’s Doom: The Dark Ages, despite receiving positive reviews, didn’t have anywhere near the cultural impact that its predecessors, Doom Eternal and Doom (2016), had.

Xbox’s Studios Have Fallen Into a Freedom Trap

Xbox Series X25 green translucent console

The biggest culprit of all these failures from Xbox is none other than Microsoft’s management, but not for the reasons people think. Xbox simply gave too much creative freedom to its developers, letting them making whatever they felt like, without any consideration for whether these titles would appeal to large-enough audiences. This is what former Xbox exec Laura Fryer has referred to as the “freedom trap”, in an insightful video she made a few days ago.

I’m sorry, but as much as I personally liked the game, why was a title featuring a walking lighthouse (Keeper) greenlit, and not Psychonauts 3? Why was Senua greenlit, and not Enslaved: Odyssey to the West 2? Why has Obsidian not been working on a Fallout game all this time?

Xbox has done a terrible job finding the balancing point between creative freedom and mass-market appeal. Sometimes, it mismanages studios into the ground; other times, it doesn’t manage them at all. As awful as this week’s layoffs have been, I can kind of understand why they happened from a cold-hearted business standpoint. I can only hope that, going forward, these changes allow Xbox to find the balancing point that it has so desperately tried to find.