Skip to content
Power Up Gaming

Why the Death of Physical Media May Not Be the End for Game Preservation

A stack of physical discs

“You will own nothing and be happy” has become somewhat of a rallying cry for physical media enthusiasts over the last few weeks. Ever since Sony announced earlier this month that it would stop printing physical releases for new PlayStation games starting in January 2028, the company has been hit with a barrage of criticism from gamers worldwide. The reasons for this backlash are many, but the primary concern that people have about this move has to do with ownership, or rather, the lack thereof.

In the future for gaming that Sony envisions, physical discs will become a thing of the past. All games will be available either digitally on the PlayStation Store or as code-in-the-box releases at major retailers. Essentially, this means that players will no longer be able to own a copy of the games that they purchase, even at full price.

Physical discs give players the ability to sell and trade games with others after finishing them. This cannot be done with digital releases; in this format, you only own a license for a video game. Said license can theoretically be revoked from you at any time, without any warning from the platform holder. Code-in-the-box releases, though technically physical, operate in exactly the same manner, since you can’t sell a code after having already redeemed it.

Game Preservation Doesn’t Die With the Death of Ownership

Keyarts of several PlayStation first-party games

If ownership for games will no longer exist (barring some unprecedented change to how the PlayStation Store operates), then what does that mean for game preservation? That’s a question that a lot of gamers have been asking themselves as of late, and it all has to do with how Sony has handed this transition from physical to digital.

I don’t have any insider knowledge as to Sony’s plans for the future, but one thing that I do know for a fact is that games will still be preserved, even with the death of physical media. How will this happen, you might ask? Well, the answer is simple: piracy.

Since the dawn of the gaming industry, publishers and developers have had to contend with unruly individuals stealing and distributing illegal copies of their games. This practice has been criticized by many executives in the industry, but soon it may become necessary to keep games around in the long term.

When a pirated copy of a game gets leaked onto the internet, it pretty much stays there forever. People are still able to access it, even if said title gets delisted from all storefronts and removed from players’ libraries. A decent example of this actually occurring can be seen with the famous Hideo Kojima-directed Silent Hills demo, P.T.

Piracy Can Preserve Delisted Digital Games Like P.T.

The word 'Piracy' on a pile of U.S. dollars

Released exclusively for the PS4, P.T. was available for free to all players on the PlayStation Store, but only as a digital release. After Silent Hills got abruptly canceled due to the fallout between Hideo Kojima and publisher Konami, the demo was removed from players’ libraries a few years after its release. Even if people had added the game to their accounts, they could never download it again if they ever deleted it.

These days, it’s not hard to find replicas of P.T. designed for PC on the internet. ROMs for the game are also available online, though they have yet to be emulated. If it were up to Konami, the only records left of this game’s existence would be playthroughs on YouTube, but thanks to fans, that isn’t the case.

I’d argue that piracy, not physical media, has always been the best way to preserve video games. I’m not necessarily advocating for people to go out and pirate the latest releases, given that that harms developers, but it’s necessary to keep digital backups of video games in order to ensure that future generations can play them.

With physical releases, people are exclusively beholden to resellers and third-party retailers in order to purchase the games they’re interested in. Some retro games, like Earthbound, are so ridiculously expensive physically, that it would be impossible for the average consumer to afford them.

Physical Media Doesn’t Last Forever, Like Digital Copies of Games Preserved on the Internet Can

A pile of blocks that spells the word internet

There’s also the matter of scarcity and erosion. Dozens of years from now, many of these physical games will decrease in number, and some of them will just become outright unplayable in their original form. If something is digitized and preserved on the internet, however, it can (at least in theory) live on forever. On top of that, people won’t have to pay any extra money to play it.

This sentiment of mine may be controversial, but it’s one that has been shared by notable preservationists, such as Video Game History Foundation director Frank Cifaldi. In a statement posted on BlueSky, Cifaldi said that the death of physical media does not have “as much of an impact as you might expect” from the perspective of professional preservationists.

Statement from VGHF director Frank Cifaldi on the discontinuation of physical PlayStation media, and the closure of the PS3 and PSP digital storefronts.

— Video Game History Foundation (@gamehistoryorg.bsky.social) 2026-07-01T18:47:35.418Z

Many of the video games released in the last two decades, he argues, were not only distributed exclusively through digital formats, but were also not released in full on physical media. The versions of the games preserved physically may not be the same as the ones that people have played. This is why physical media has never actually been the optimal method to preserve games in the long run.

In a time when ownership is being stripped away from gamers, piracy will soon become the only way to keep video games playable for as long as possible. To quote another internet maxim related to this matter, “if buying isn’t owning, then piracy isn’t stealing.”