Skip to content
Power Up Gaming

Leaked Gears of War: E-Day Review Suggests the Game May Not Be as Good as Expected

Gears of War: E-Day screenshot of locust

Gears of War: E-Day is only a couple days away from being released. The highly-anticipated game, developed by Canadian studio The Coalition, was announced a few years ago during an Xbox Games Showcase. At the time, reception to its reveal was very positive, as the game seemed to differ significantly in tone compared to the more recent Gears of War titles, like Gears 4 and 5. Instead of having a vibrant colour palette, the game’s reveal trailer had a considerably darker, grittier tone, with an emphasis on horror that hadn’t been seen since the early titles in the series.

As its name suggests, E-Day is a prequel to Xbox’s long-running Gears of War franchise. It is set during the titular Emergence Day, an event in which the Locust Horde first emerged from the ground and launched a surprise attack on humanity. The protagonists of the game, a young Marcus Fenix and Dom Santiago, have to survive the invasion of the city of Kalona, as they struggle to maintain their sanity during the collapse of civilisation.

Many long-time Gears fans expect that this game will be a return to form for the Microsoft-owned series, given that it takes a lot of inspiration from the franchise’s original trilogy. However, a recently-leaked review for the title has cast doubts on its overall quality.

A Review for Gears of War: E-Day Was Accidentally Posted Early Online

Gears of War E-Day

Earlier today, The Guardian accidentally posted its review for Gears of War: E-Day on its official website. The review was taken down shortly thereafter due to it breaking embargo. Power Up Gaming has seen this review, however, so we can share some of the thoughts that the reviewer had on the game.

The Guardian’s review for Gears of War: E-Day is titled “an alien invasion shouldn’t be this boring,” and it gives the game a score of 3/5. Although the person who wrote the review says that E-Day’s combat is the best that the Gears of War series has ever had, they claim that basically everything else surrounding the combat is relatively disappointing (at least when it comes to the game’s single-player campaign).

The reviewer highlighted several notable issues with the game, such as ludonarrative dissonance caused by excessive collectibles, disruptive audio chimes that play when players are near said collectibles, and a lack of focused, linear levels in the game. According to this person’s opinion, there are too many large, open areas in Gears of War: E-Day. The level design is somewhat similar to Gears 5 in that sense, but unlike that game, E-Day doesn’t have any vehicles, so players have to traverse every level on foot.

Gears of War: E-Day’s Flaws Seem Fairly Significant

An enemy in Gears of War: E-Day

To make matters worse, the campaign as a whole is somewhat repetitive. Not only is there a lack of variety when it comes to side quests (most of them are just short horde missions), there is also limited diversity in gameplay. The reviewer cites missions that involve “a helicopter gunning section” and “a slow-walking stretch during which characters talk to you” as some of the few examples of unique gameplay moments in the game.

Gears of War: E-Day takes place entirely within the city of Kalona. Players never actually leave the city in the game, so there are moments during the campaign in which they are required to revisit locations that they have already been to. There’s a bridge in E-Day, the reviewer claims, that players have to go across three times throughout the entire campaign. Even though its levels are fairly large in size, E-Day doesn’t give gamers the ability to explore their surroundings whenever they want. Sometimes, stepping outside of the mission objective area triggers an instant mission failure, which seems at odds with how open the game’s levels are.

The Guardian’s review, from what we can tell, doesn’t comment much on the quality of Gears of War: E-Day’s story or its multiplayer modes. However, if this review ends up representing the general sentiment surrounding the game, then fans should probably keep their expectations in check before playing E-Day. It is entirely possible, of course, that this reviewer’s opinion will be an outlier, but their gripes with the game do seem pretty significant nonetheless. We’ll have to wait until October 1 to see how Gears of War: E-Day ends up faring among reviewers and fans.