Skip to content
Power Up Gaming

Double Fine Has to Shake Things Up if It Wants to Sustain Itself

A phoenix-style logo for Double Fine

Double Fine is one of those studios that a lot of people have probably heard of, but not a lot have actually played its games. Founded by the legendary game designer Tim Schafer, the studio has been around for more than 20 years, though most of its projects are relatively niche in terms of their appeal. Aside from 2005’s Psychonauts and 2009’s Brutal Legend, the majority of Double Fine’s games haven’t reached mainstream audiences.

This, however, didn’t stop Microsoft from acquiring Double Fine and its assets back in 2019. As part of its acquisition spree during the late 2010s, the console manufacturer bought up Tim Schafer’s studio and took over the publishing rights for its then-upcoming title, Psychonauts 2. With funding from Microsoft, Double Fine was able to see Psychonauts 2’s development to completion, without cutting corners in any major areas.

Psychonauts 2 received widespread critical acclaim when it debuted in 2021, and it seemingly did pretty well for itself performance-wise. The game sold 1.7 million copies as of April 2022, making it Double Fine’s best-performing game in the history of the company. Despite being published by Microsoft, Psychonauts 2 was fully multiplatform, which perhaps contributed to its commercial triumph.

Double Fine Has Parted Ways With Microsoft

Official logo for Double Fine without text

After experiencing great success with this title, one might have expected Microsoft to keep this studio under its wings for as long as possible. As you may already know by now, though, that didn’t happen. A few weeks ago, Microsoft announced that it would be divesting Double Fine from its Xbox Games Studios division as part of a greater Xbox reset. Many staff at Double Fine were laid off as a result of this shift to independence, but the company is still up and running as of today.

Double Fine has a lot of clout behind its name; why, then, did Microsoft let go of the company? I think the answer lies in how the studio has been handled as of late, and in its most recent releases.

In its seven years as a Microsoft subsidiary, Double Fine released only three games under the Xbox Games Studios banner: the aforementioned Psychonauts 2, as well as Keeper and Kiln. The latter two titles were the only ones that were completely developed under Microsoft from start to finish, meaning that they had the full financial backing of the platform holder.

The Games Double Fine Released Under Microsoft Were a Mixed Bag

The character creator in Kiln

Keeper and Kiln were released in 2025 and 2026, respectively, about four years after the launch of Psychonauts 2. Unlike its predecessor, these two titles were a lot more niche than most had probably expected. Keeper was a short, five-hour walking sim featuring a walking lighthouse, while Kiln was a multiplayer party brawler centered around pottery.

Just from their descriptions alone, you can tell that these games likely didn’t perform that well, and you’d be right to make that assumption. Keeper and Kiln both failed to surpass the 200 concurrent player count mark on Steam, according to SteamDB. While the titles were also available on Xbox Game Pass at launch, neither of them shot up the charts upon their respective releases.

I’m no financial expert, but in my opinion, a company cannot sustain itself by taking four years to make two games that fail to attract players. The fact that Double Fine seemingly put all its resources into making such projects is a serious indictment on the management of the company, and on Xbox Game Studios’ leadership as a whole.

Double Fine Should Have Made More Games on the Scale of Psychonauts 2

A gameplay screenshot of Psychonauts 2

Keeper and Kiln are not bad games, per se; as a matter, I loved Keeper when I first tried it out. But even I, as an armchair analyst, could have easily predicted that this game wouldn’t sell or attract many players on Game Pass. Yet it still got greenlit, alongside another title (Kiln) that was even more niche.

I’m not saying Double Fine should never make niche games, but when you get acquired by a company as massive as Microsoft, the expectation is that you will take advantage of the resources available to you to the fullest extent. That’s not what happened with Double Fine, though.

Instead of making more games on the level of Psychonauts 2, which clearly had a sizable budget behind it, Double Fine decided to develop more small-scale titles, similar to the ones that it was already creating when it was independent. I believe that this wasn’t a smart choice to make. If Double Fine wanted to prove to Microsoft that it was worth the acquisition cost, then it should have worked on a project similar to Psychonauts 2 and Brutal Legend, in addition to these niche, indie-scale titles. Said titles also shouldn’t take so long to make.

Double Fine Has a Clear Path Ahead of It That It Should Take

A gameplay screenshot of Keeper

Ideally, Double Fine should have released Keeper about a year or two after Psychonauts 2’s debut. It should have then focused on making a new, large-scale project, while pushing back Kiln to a later date. It’s too late to change things now, though, so I suppose there’s not much point in mulling over what could’ve been.

Double Fine has recently launched a Kickstarter for fans to choose the direction of its next video game. Now that the company is fully independent again, it should be more careful when deciding the path that it should take. Rather than focusing exclusively on passion projects that very few people would play, Double Fine should make titles that retain the charm it’s known for, while still being approachable enough to attract a sizable audience. Once again, Psychonauts 2 is a perfect example of how this can be done. But will Double Fine actually follow this strategy? Only time will tell.